Only an hour and fifteen minutes from Pittsburgh, below is our recommended weekend itinerary as the town celebrates its annual Peanut Butter Festival.
Looking for a weekend escape packed with local flavor, small-town charm, and a dash of adventure? Head to New Bethlehem this September, when the town comes alive for the annual Peanut Butter Festival. From the scenic Redbank Valley Trail to the quirky festivities downtown, a two-day trip here blends rural beauty with one-of-a-kind fun you won’t find anywhere else.
Day One
Morning
Fuel up for the day’s adventures with coffee and pastries from the Canyon Coffee Co. You can dine in at their seating areas or take your breakfast to-go if you’re in a hurry to get to your next stop.
After breakfast, head a few doors down the street to the Redbank Valley Historical Society and tour their exhibits to learn more about the rich history and culture of the Redbank Valley area. Once you’re done exploring the museum, you can walk down to The Gallery at New Bethlehem Town Center to browse their local art exhibits.
Afternoon
Grab lunch at one of the nearby eateries, like Evermoore Restaurant, before hitting the Redbank Valley Trail for some light hiking or bicycling.
The Redbank Valley Trail spans over 51 miles in total and cuts through the center of town. If you go west, you’ll meet up with the Redbank Creek just outside of town and have an unfettered view of the water for several miles– perfect for a quick cast with your fishing rod.
If you follow the trail to the east, you’ll have access to some great lunch spots, as well as some fast food options like Burger King and Subway. This side of the trail opens up to swaths of forests outside of town, immersing you in nature all the way to Brookville, PA.
Evening
Check into your lodging and get your things situated before having dinner. The Blose Brothers Trail Side Airbnb (formerly the Trail-side Stay) and the New Bethlehem Town Center Inn are both nearby the hiking trail and local eateries. You can easily travel to one of the many nearby pizzerias like Joe’s Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant for dinner. Known for its authentic Italian flavors and fresh, homemade bread, Joe’s is the perfect spot to sit down for a comforting meal.
Day Two
Morning
If you enjoyed yesterday’s lunch, head back to Evermoore Restaurant for a hearty breakfast to kick off your second day. Then, spend some time browsing the many local shops in town. Three Chicks from the Sticks and Valley Thrift Shop are great stops if you’re into antiques and vintage items, while Valley Flowers and Gift Shoppe and Pine Springs Pottery are great places to find novelty and artisan items. Just be sure to call ahead to schedule your visit with potter, Marie Lewis.
Afternoon
Head to Gumtown Park to join in the excitement of this year’s Peanut Butter Festival! On a normal day, the park is a peaceful spot for picnics, fishing, or kayaking along the Redbank Creek. During the festival, it transforms into a lively hub of activity and community spirit.
Spend the afternoon browsing vendor stalls filled with handmade crafts and local specialties, or sample peanut butter-themed treats. And be sure to grab a good spot along the parade route to catch the annual Peanut Butter Festival Parade mid-afternoon.
Evening
Wrap up your weekend with dinner at a local restaurant you haven’t tried yet, or stop by one of the many food stalls at the festival. As evening settles in, head back to the festival stage for a lively concert featuring local bands. Then cap off your visit with the grand finale: a dazzling fireworks display over the Redbank Creek at dusk!
Planning Your Trip
If this sounds like your idea of an amazing weekend getaway, start planning your trip to New Bethlehem!
Places to Stay
Blose Brothers Trail Side Airbnb
This locally owned Airbnb offers modern comfort with easy access to the trail and is ideal for couples, small groups, or solo travelers.
New Bethlehem Town Center Inn
Centrally located with easy walking access to restaurants, shops, and the trail, this no-frills inn offers great value for your stay.
Redbank Valley Municipal Park
For those who prefer sleeping under the stars, the Municipal Park offers spacious campsites and RV hookups, plus access to trails and recreation.
Places to Eat
Evermoore Restaurant
A hometown favorite serving classic American dishes, hearty breakfasts, and homestyle meals in a friendly, welcoming environment.
Canyon Coffee Co.
A cozy café known for specialty lattes, fresh-baked pastries, and a relaxed vibe that is perfect for a morning pick-me-up or mid-day treat.
Joe’s Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant
Serving up delicious pizza, pasta, and classic Italian entrees with generous portions and local charm.
New China King
A go-to spot for Chinese takeout favorites, offering quick service and a large menu of flavorful dishes.
Places to Shop
The Gallery at New Bethlehem Town Center
A rotating gallery of local art, handmade goods, and creative displays. It is perfect for finding one-of-a-kind pieces from area artists.
Pine Springs Pottery
Handmade pottery from local potter, Marie Lewis.
Valley Thrift Shop
Hunt for vintage finds, gently used clothing, and secondhand gems in this local favorite thrift store.
Three Chicks From the Sticks
A unique boutique in an old church featuring antiques, country décor, and handmade crafts—perfect for those who love rustic charm.
Valley Flowers and Gift Shoppe
Stop in for beautiful floral arrangements, seasonal décor, and thoughtful gifts made with local flair.
Ready to start planning your weekend? Use our trip planning tool to map out your stay and don’t forget to book your preferred lodging in advance!